Society for Psychophysiological Research
Vancouver, Canada
Oct. 18, 1996

Symposium

Time-Frequency Analysis of
Event-Related Brain Dynamics


Organizer: Scott Makeig
Institutions: Institute for Neural Computation, University of California San Diego
Address: La Jolla CA 92093
Email: smakeig@ucsd.edu
Phone: (858) 453-4100 x1455
FAX: (858) 587-0417

Currently, the predominant analysis tool for studying event-related electrical and magnetic brain dynamics is time-domain response averaging. Its products (ERPs, ERFs) reveal brain activity reliably locked in both time and phase (positive or negative) to reference events. However, time- and phase-locked activity is only one class of event-related brain dynamics. Another class, event-related changes in power and/or coherence of the ongoing EEG or MEG spectrum, occur over a wide range of frequencies (~1-100+ Hz) and time scales (msecs-minutes), and can be measured by averaging time-frequency transforms of event-related EEG or MEG epochs. Narrow-band (ERD/ERS) measures of changes in EEG spectral amplitude have been in use for many years; full-spectrum time-frequency amplitude and coherence transforms are newer research tools. Time-frequency averages measure event-related perturbations or modulations of the spectral character of the EEG/MEG itself, whereas evoked responses typically amount to only a small fraction of the recorded brain signals. Like ERPs, time-frequency transforms vary both with cognitive state and with stimulus significance. They reveal cognitive event-related brain dynamics lasting longer than the maximum (<1s) latency of most (>DC) ERP phenomena, and thus are prime candidates for relating to concurrent changes in brain blood flow. The symposium will give a technical overview and survey current work in this emerging research area.

(Links to web pages on time-frequency analysis ...)

[This is a yellowbar divider.]

Event-related spectral perturbations


Author(s): Scott Makeig(1,2) and Tzyy-Ping Jung(1,3)
Institution(s): (1)Naval Health Research Center, San Diego, CA; (2)Institute for Neural Computation, University of California San Diego, and (3)Computational Neurobiology Laboratory, The Salk Institute
Address: La Jolla CA 92037
Email: smakeig@ucsd.edu
Phone: (858) 453-4100 x1455
FAX: (858) 587-0417

Abstract:

From Berger's very first EEG reports, nonstationarity in the spectral character of the EEG, as well as apparent consistency in the EEG spectral changes accompanying changes in wakefulness and attention were noted to be outstanding traits of EEG signals. In 1977, Pfurtscheller described a method of averaging the time course of event-related reductions in power in a narrow frequency-band and called the phenomena event-related desynchronization (ERD). During the last decade, increasing observations of subcortical brain centers which modulate spontaneous and event-related cortical activity, and suggestions that subcortical and cortical oscillations may serve to transiently synchronize or 'bind' activity in separate brain areas have fueled interest in observing the dynamics of EEG/MEG modulation and synchronization processes noninvasively in humans. Makeig (1993) demonstrated that averaging broad band time-frequency transforms of event-related EEG epochs in an auditory attention experiment revealed precisely-timed, both narrow- and wide-band perturbations in the power spectrum of the ongoing EEG, phenomena called event-related spectral perturbations (ERSPs). ERSPs need not fit into traditionally-defined frequency bands, and often exceed the durations and latencies of supra-DC components of event-related potentials. Time-frequency averaging may be accomplished by several methods (FFT, wavelet and Wigner transforms, matching pursuit, etc.) Both electric and magnetic spectral perturbations have definitely been shown to depend on cognitive processing as well as on stimulus character, and may represent both transient amplitude modulation of ongoing brain activity, or transient changes in synchronization of activity in previously desynchronous brain areas.

[This is a yellowbar divider.]

Event-related gamma band activity indicates binding in Hebbian cortical networks

Author(s): N. Birbaumer, F. Pulvermueller, W. Lutzenberger & H. Preissl
Institution(s): University of Tuebingen
Department: Institute of Medical Psychology and Behavioral Neurobiology
Address: Gartenstr. 29, D-72074 Tuebingen, Germany
Email: niels.birbaumer@mailserv.uni-tuebingen.de
Phone: (49)7071 294219
FAX: (49)7071 295956

Abstract:

In a series of experiments with meaningful and non-meaningful visual and verbal stimulus material the hypothesis of a functional role of high frequency brain oscillations for the construction of meaning was tested. EEG-frequency bands were analyzed in 10 Hz wide windows between 10 and 80 Hz in the time-frequency domain as described by S. Makeig. In the visual modality, an irregular pattern of horizontal lines in the four visual fields changed into an orderly Gestalt-like pattern (waterfall appearance). Over occipital cortices only, spectral power in the 35-45 Hz frequency band increased significantly during the gestalt-like patterns. A similar effect was seen in the 25-35 Hz range over left perisylvian cortices for meaningful words in comparison to meaningless pseudowords. These data support a Hebbian model of Gestalt processing in the brain as deduced from animal experiments with simultaneously moving visual stimuli (Singer 1995). Supported by the German Research Society (DFG).

[This is a yellowbar divider.]

Characterization of P3 using matching pursuit

Author(s): B. Shen(1) & John J. B. Allen(2)
Institution(s): (1) New Jersey Neuroscience Institute, JFK medical center (2) Psychology Department, University of Arizona
Address: 65 James Str. P.O. Box 3059, Edison NJ08818-3059
Email: bshen@jfk.hbocvan.com
Phone: (908)321-7000x2551
FAX: (908)632-1584

Abstract:

To enhance the signal-to-noise ratio, event-related potentials (ERPs) are often averaged over many trials of repeated stimuli. However, this approach presumes that cognitive processes remain stationary over those trials, which may not be valid in many experimental paradigms. Traditional single-trial methods are heuristic and have failed to extract information from noisy signals reliably. A recently developed technique, matching pursuit (Mallat and Zhang, 1993), offers adaptive time-frequency decomposition and has been shown to be effective in hippocampal EEG analysis (Shen et al., 1995) and ERP studies (Allen et al., 1995). In this study, we use matching pursuit analysis to study the statistics and the time frequency character of the classic P3 components of the ERPs in a memory-assessment task. The P3 was mathematically modeled by an adaptive Gaussian waveform while oscillatory wavelets were screened out. This method offered a better measure of P3s because its signal-to-noise ratio of a single-trial ERP was larger. The statistics of the amplitudes, the latencies and the durations of single-trial P3s were more informative than the averaged ERP amplitudes. The correlation between the P3s and other time-frequency components suggested that there existed a distinct time-frequency character of the P3 components. This approach provides a new method for examining ERP data, and a means of accessing the non-stationarity of cognitive processes.

[This is a yellowbar divider.]

Stimulus induced coherence: a measure for interareal synchronization

Author(s): Astrid von Stein
Institution(s): The Neurosciences Institute, San Diego, CA, Institute of Neurophysiology, University of Vienna, Austria The Neurosciences Institute, 10640 John Jay Hopkins Drive San Diego CA 92121
Email: astein@nsi.edu
Fax: (619) 626-2099

Abstract:

A paradigm shift has occurred in neurobiology. The old concept of single cell coding is being replaced by coding in DISTRIBUTED NEURONAL CELL ENSEMBLES. Results from cat intracortical recordings have shown that synchronization among the members of a cell ensemble play a major role in this process. This makes it desirable to measure synchronization also in humans. In my talk I will show that synchronization of neuronal cell ensembles can be detected in the frequency components of human scalp EEG. According to our results, spectral power in the high beta and in lower frequency ranges reflects the degree of synchronization between columns within a cortical area (von Stein et al. 1995). Furthermore coherence, the normalized crosspower between two cortical signals, gives us the possibility to determine synchronization BETWEEN DIFFERENT CORTICAL AREAS. These interareal synchronizations are of specific importance for higher cortical processes where neuronal ensembles are thought to extend over large distances. I will present data on local and interareal synchronization during auditory and visual perception and during several higher cognitive tasks. We present stimuli lasting for 1-2 s and measure the averaged power/ crosspower spectra over 30-50 trials. We find significant task-specific increases of coherence between visual cortex and associative cortex during visual perception, between several sites in parietal cortex of both hemispheres during spatial imagery tasks, between temporal and parietal cortex during feature integration, and more. Changes occur in single frequency ranges or in combinations of frequency ranges. These induced interareal synchronizations are usually reproducible within single subjects and reveal significant consistencies for groups of subjects. Thus, EEG coherence analysis seems to be an adequate tool for measuring synchronization within extended neuronal ensembles directly in humans.

[This is a yellowbar divider.]

Event-related power shifts in the theta and alpha bands during encoding and retrieval

Author(s): Wolfgang Klimesch
Institution(s): Department of Physiological Psychology, University of Salzburg,
Address: Hellbrunnerstr. 34, A-5020 Salzburg, Austria
Email: Wolfgang.Klimesch@sbg.ac.at
Fax: 0043 662 8044 5126

Abstract:

The results of two memory experiments are reported which indicate that theta synchronization (increase in event-related band power) is associated with episodic memory processes. In Experiment 1, a recognition task, the EEG was recorded during the study phase in which 96 target words were presented and during actual recognition. The results indicate that a) in the study phase those words that can later be remembered show significantly more theta synchronization as compared to words that cannot be recognized later and that b) during actual recognition, correctly recognized targets exhibit significantly more theta synchronization as compared to distractors and not recognized targets. For the alpha band it was found that successful encoding is associated with desynchronization in the lower but not in the upper alpha band. In order to rule out the possibility that theta synchronization simply reflects increased effort and/or attention that accompanies successful encoding or retrieval, an incidental free recall task was carried in Experiment 2. In the study phase, subjects categorized the target words of Experiment 1. Then, without prior warning subjects had to free recall the words. As in Experiment 1, those words that were remembered later showed significantly stronger synchronization in the theta band. In the alpha band, no significant differences between remembered and not remembered words were observed. The findings are discussed with respect to a possible involvement of hippocampal theta, induced in the cortex via hippocampo-cortical feedback loops.